Butter Cat Myth: A Mythical Creature You Never Knew

The internet is a breeding ground for strange myths and quirky legends.

One such peculiar story that has intrigued animal lovers and mythbusters alike is the “butter cat” myth, often referred to in Scandinavian folklore as the Smörkatt (Swedish) or Smørkatt (Norwegian).

This tale has been passed down through generations, but what exactly does it entail?

Is there any truth to it, or is it simply a fun, albeit misguided, piece of folklore?

In this article, we’ll explore the origins of the butter cat, examine its spread, analyze its impact on both cats and their owners, and finally debunk the myth using science.

What is Butter Cat (Smörkatt/Smørkatt)?

The butter cat myth, also known as Smörkatt (Swedish) or Smørkatt (Norwegian), is a strange legend with supernatural roots.

According to this tale, cats—especially black or gray ones—were believed to take part in magical rituals.

The myth suggests that if you rubbed butter on a cat’s back, it would either perform magical acts or act as a messenger between the human and spirit worlds.

This idea comes from old Scandinavian traditions, where cats were often linked to witchcraft and mystical powers.

Some versions of the story also say that buttered cats could bring good luck or protect homes from evil spirits.

• Read also: Mythbusting Cat Care – Separating Fact from Fiction
• Read also: Can Cats See Spirits? The Truth Behind Feline Mythology

Main Versions of the Butter Cat Myth

The butter cat myth has taken on different forms over the years, with various regions and time periods offering their own unique versions of the story.

Here are three of the most well-known versions of the myth:

The supernatural companion

In this version, buttering a cat’s back turns it into a “familiar” – a magical companion often associated with witches.

The idea was that the butter gave the cat special powers, allowing it to assist in casting spells or performing other magical tasks.

Some believed the buttered cat could travel between different dimensions or communicate with spirits.

This version of the myth ties in with old folklore, where cats, especially black ones, were seen as mysterious creatures linked to the supernatural.

The fortune bringer

In another variation, buttering a cat’s back was thought to bring good luck, especially around the time of harvest.

Farmers believed that by smearing butter on their cats, they could bless their land and ensure a successful season.

It wasn’t just about the harvest, though—people also buttered their cats during important events, hoping it would attract prosperity and protect their homes from misfortune.

The mischief-maker

The third popular version of the butter cat myth involves a more playful or superstitious twist.

People would spread butter on a cat’s back as a kind of test or prank.

According to this version, the cat’s reaction would determine the household’s future.

For example, if the cat ran away or acted strangely, it might be seen as a bad omen.

This version plays into the idea of cats being mysterious and unpredictable, with their behavior holding clues to the future.

Spread of the Myth

The butter cat legend most likely began in rural Scandinavian villages, where superstitions and folklore were an important part of everyday life.

Like many old stories, it was passed down by word of mouth, probably growing more exaggerated with each retelling.

As time went on, the myth spread beyond Scandinavia and became part of the larger European folklore.

In recent years, the internet has given this quirky legend a new life.

Online communities have revived the butter cat myth, often sharing it in a humorous or playful way, adding a modern twist to this ancient tale.

Potential Consequences of the Myth

Harm to cats and their owners

Though the butter cat myth might seem harmless, it can actually cause real problems for both cats and their owners.

Rubbing butter or any greasy substance on a cat’s fur can make the animal uncomfortable.

Since cats are natural groomers, they will lick their fur to clean themselves, and ingesting too much butter can upset their stomach, causing issues like diarrhea or vomiting.

Additionally, the butter can irritate their skin, leading to other health concerns.

Misinformation and misconceptions about animal behavior

The butter cat myth also spreads misleading ideas about how animals behave.

Cats are often seen as mysterious or aloof, but their actions are based on biology, not magic.

Beliefs like this myth can distort our understanding of animals, feeding into false stereotypes.

For example, myths about cats being connected to evil or magic can reinforce negative views of these animals.

Negative impact on animal welfare

Superstitions can sometimes lead to mistreatment of animals.

Historically, in medieval Europe, black cats were feared and even killed because they were believed to be linked to witchcraft.

While the butter cat myth isn’t as extreme, it can still promote negative ideas about cats in certain cultures, which may lead to neglect or even abuse.

Misunderstanding animal behavior based on myths can harm the way people treat and care for animals.

Scientific Disproof

From a scientific point of view, there’s absolutely no evidence to suggest that buttering a cat has any magical or supernatural effects.

Cats’ behavior is driven by instinct, and when they lick butter off their fur, it’s simply their natural reaction to feeling uncomfortable—not anything mystical.

In fact, butter is high in fats, which can upset a cat’s digestive system.

Studies, like one published in the Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, show that feeding cats fatty human foods can cause digestive problems and even pancreatitis, a serious and potentially life-threatening condition.

So, instead of bringing good luck, buttering a cat is more likely to bring a big vet bill!

• Read also: Myth Buster: Why do Cats have Nine Lives?
• Read also: Myth or Fact: Can Pets Predict Natural Disasters?

Final Thoughts

While the butter cat myth may provide some entertainment and insight into the superstitions of the past, it’s important to remember that it’s just that—a myth.

As fun as it might be to imagine buttered cats working magic or bringing good luck, the reality is far less exciting.

Cats are fascinating creatures in their own right, and we don’t need to attribute supernatural powers to them to appreciate their companionship.

Understanding the myth, its spread, and the potential consequences it has for animal welfare can help ensure that we treat cats—and all animals—with the respect and care they deserve.